Heating oil delivery in the Town of Oyster Bay
Today's cash price in Massapequa (11758): $4.699/gal for 150–199 gal, before tax · card $4.899 · November 9, 2026
Page updated
Alcus Fuel Oil & Sons is a family oil company just over the Nassau line, at 238 Broadway, Amityville. We've delivered home heating oil since 1988, and we deliver across the Town of Oyster Bay, from Massapequa to Syosset and Oyster Bay.
Our price is set by ZIP code. Woodbury (11797), Syosset (11791) and Oyster Bay (11771) are farther from our yard and carry a small per-gallon difference from Massapequa and the south-shore hamlets, so check your own ZIP in the price box.
Pay cash to the driver, or by card online or by phone. 25-gallon minimum, no contract, HEAP accepted.
Today's price for your ZIP
Do we deliver to you?
One posted price for cards — pay cash and save 20¢/gal.
Every hamlet we deliver to in the Town of Oyster Bay
| Hamlet / village | ZIP | From our yard (straight line) | Cash price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Massapequa | 11758 | about 3.0 mi | $4.699/gal |
| North Massapequa | 11758 | about 3.1 mi | $4.699/gal |
| East Massapequa | 11758 | about 1.1 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Massapequa Park (village) | 11762 | about 1.7 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Farmingdale (village) (ZIP 11735 also covers East Farmingdale, across the Town of Babylon line) | 11735 | about 3.9 mi | $4.699/gal |
| South Farmingdale | 11735 | about 3.0 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Plainedge | 11714, 11756, 11758 | about 4.4 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Bethpage | 11714 | about 6.0 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Old Bethpage | 11804 | about 5.3 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Plainview | 11803 | about 7.6 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Hicksville | 11801 | about 8.1 mi | $4.699/gal |
| Woodbury | 11797 | about 10.1 mi | $4.769/gal |
| Syosset | 11791 | about 10.4 mi | $4.769/gal |
| Oyster Bay | 11771 | about 14.3 mi | $4.769/gal |
Cash price per gallon for 150–199 gal, before tax, for each row's ZIP. Card is 20¢ more per gallon. East Farmingdale shares ZIP 11735 but is in the Town of Babylon: see Town of Babylon heating oil. Further east in Suffolk: Town of Islip heating oil. Next door in Nassau: Town of Hempstead heating oil. All prices by ZIP · Nassau County heating oil · Full service area
A family oil company next door
Our yard is at 238 Broadway, Amityville, a few minutes east of the Massapequa line by Merrick Road, Sunrise Highway or Route 110. The south-shore hamlets (Massapequa, Massapequa Park, Bethpage, Farmingdale and Plainedge) are our nearest Nassau routes; Plainview, Hicksville, Woodbury, Syosset and Oyster Bay are farther north.
Most orders are delivered within 1–2 business days, depending on the weather and how busy we are. We can't promise same-day. Automatic-delivery and service-contract customers are served first in cold snaps.
Tanks and homes in the Town of Oyster Bay
Most homes here have a 275-gallon tank in the basement; others have an outdoor tank or one in the garage. Massapequa, Bethpage, Plainview and Hicksville are mostly post-war capes, ranches, high-ranches and split-levels, and many still have the original-era tank. Syosset and Woodbury have more colonials and larger homes on bigger lots, and Oyster Bay has older colonials and Victorians, so long driveways, gates and hard-to-spot fill pipes are common: put them in your order notes. If your tank is decades old or shows rust or wet spots, see oil tank replacement.
Parts of Massapequa near the water, south of Merrick Road, are in FEMA flood zones. You can look up your address on FEMA's flood map. If flood water has reached your tank or fill pipe, call us before your next delivery.
Nassau sales tax
Nassau County homes pay no sales tax on residential heating oil (no Nassau County tax and no New York State tax). Two ZIPs touch the county line: Massapequa 11758 is almost all Nassau County; a tiny edge touches Suffolk. Farmingdale 11735 is split: the Village of Farmingdale and South Farmingdale are in Nassau County, East Farmingdale (Town of Babylon) is in Suffolk County. Tax follows the county your street address is in. More in heating oil sales tax in Nassau and Suffolk.
HEAP in the Town of Oyster Bay
We accept HEAP. The Town of Oyster Bay is in Nassau County:
- Apply online through New York State (myBenefits), or
- Call the Nassau County Department of Social Services HEAP unit at 516-227-8519.
- Then call us at 631-264-8800 to confirm your benefit before you order.
No heat?
Call 631-264-8800 — no heat? Call us and we'll get your heat back on. What to do now →
Office hours: Monday–Friday 8 am–4:30 pm, Saturday 8 am–12 pm, Sunday closed.
What customers say on Google
“I am a customer of over 10 years and have found my experiences with the company to be outstanding, including the professionalism and courtesy of the employees along with the quality of the service. Such attributes were in full effect when I needed service during the recent inclement weather. The representative who delivered the heating oil, Tom, was in his usual good-nature form, despite the harsh conditions. It was a joy interacting with him along with the dispatcher who kept me posted on the status of the delivery. I look forward to continuing the relationship with the company.”
“I have lived at my home for 20 years, I haved used multiple oil companies. However Alcus fuel is #1 Oil Company,When I call to schedule a delivery the customer service reps are great, the oil delivery guy Tom is amazing, he sets me at ease and makes me feel comfortable, and last but not least, the heating oil is premium, it does not run out fast and its not watered down. Happy Holidays Alcus.”
“Very polite and helpful, I highly recommend them for any oil or propane needs”
Town of Oyster Bay heating oil questions
Do you deliver heating oil to the whole Town of Oyster Bay?
We deliver to Massapequa, North Massapequa, East Massapequa, Massapequa Park, Farmingdale, South Farmingdale, Plainedge, Bethpage, Old Bethpage, Plainview, Hicksville, Woodbury, Syosset and Oyster Bay. Each one is in the table above with a link to its own page. The minimum delivery is 25 gallons. Not sure about your street? Call 631-264-8800.
Which Town of Oyster Bay ZIP codes do you deliver to?
11714, 11735, 11756, 11758, 11762, 11771, 11791, 11797, 11801, 11803, 11804. ZIP 11735 is shared with East Farmingdale, which is in the Town of Babylon (Suffolk County).
Is the price the same in Syosset, Woodbury and Oyster Bay as in Massapequa?
Not always. Our price is set by ZIP code. Woodbury (11797), Syosset (11791) and Oyster Bay (11771) are farther from our yard and carry a small per-gallon difference from Massapequa and the south-shore hamlets, so check your own ZIP in the price box.
Is there a minimum delivery or a contract?
The minimum delivery is 25 gallons, and there's no contract. Order online or by phone when you need oil (COD / will-call), or sign up for automatic delivery.
How fast can you deliver in the Town of Oyster Bay?
Most orders are delivered within 1–2 business days, depending on the weather and how busy we are. We can't promise same-day. Out of oil? Call 631-264-8800.
Is heating oil taxed in the Town of Oyster Bay?
Nassau County homes pay no sales tax on residential heating oil (no Nassau County tax and no New York State tax). The Town of Oyster Bay is in Nassau County. Only ZIPs that cross the county line (11735 and 11758) can be different: the tax follows the county your street address is in.